As December (and all of 2008) drew to a close, Sox fans were hanging their heads with the news that the Evil Empire had reeled in a stud first baseman (Mark Teixeira), a stud starting pitcher (C. C. Sabathia), and a guy who always seems to pitch well in his contract year (A. J. Burnett). A simple turn of the calendar page has caused a Boston buzz as five potential key free agents were added to provide depth to an already strong 2009 Red Sox club. While none of the acquisitions are equal in talent and cost to the recent spending spree of the Yankees, all offer great upside with good health, careful monitoring, and a little luck.Brad Penney -- The upside here is that he simply returns to the dominant form that he was in 2006 and 2007 when he won 32 games. Brought to Boston in an incentive-laden one-year deal for a guaranteed $5 million, Penney is playing for his 2010 contract while performing for Red Sox fans in 2009. That's a nice place for the Red Sox to be. Truth be told, Penney is expected to leave Fort Myers in good health (shoulder tendinitis dogged him with the Dodgers in 2008) and a contributing member of the opening day starting rotation. Keep in mind that Penney is making the switch from the laid back National League West to the pressure cooker of the American League East.
Rocco Baldelli -- Lured away from the defending American League champion Tampa Bay Rays, Baldelli returns to his hometown as a fourth outfielder. Baldelli's guaranteed money is a paltry $500,000 in 2009 with a strange bunch of incentives that can greatly increase his salary. While some of his incentives kick in just for good health and remaining on the active roster, some of the incentives call for an outlandish number of plate appearances (600) that no fourth outfielder in the history of the game could possibly attain. Baldelli's right handed bat is clearly important to the team's outfield situation (Drew and Ellsbury), so guys like the lefty hitting
Jim Edmonds were not likely to catch the interest of Sox GM
Theo Epstein. Keep in mind how often
J. D. Drew finds himself injured; then take a look at the number of games Baldelli has played the past two seasons. Without a doubt, there is some serious risk here, but the low money and potential upside could reap huge benefits for both the Red Sox and Baldelli.
Mark Kotsay -- Thanks to a market that took a huge downturn for second-tier free agents, Kotsay was not the apple of anyone's eye as a starting outfielder this offseason. All of baseball watched Kotsay play a very solid first base in the American League Champion Series last fall, and Kotsay felt he had one more go-around as a full-time player in his future. Kotsay's value to the 2009 Red Sox is his ability to play all three outfield positions (especially center field) as well as first base. For a known entity like Kotsay, $1.5 million in guaranteed salary sounds just right to the Red Sox. In a perfect world, Kotsay will not have to exceed 175 plate appearances.
John Smoltz -- Future Hall of Famer Smoltz brings his legendary competitive spirit to the Red Sox after a tremendous twenty-year career as an Atlanta Brave. Smoltz, on $5 million guaranteed money, is not expected to be a factor until mid-May at the earliest, as he is recovering from serious arm surgery at age 41. Smoltz is never to be underestimated, and his signing most assuredly slams the door on the team bringing back
Curt Schilling. In a perfect world, this class act contributes 15-18 quality starts in the second half of the season, and the Sox ride him into the playoffs.
Takashi Saito -- As of this writing, Saito is the newest Red Sox and maybe their quietest offseason signing (next to utility infielder
Nick Green). Saito, 39, is recovering from non-surgical treatment for a serious arm issue. Experts say that Saito is likely to pitch again, but not as a closer. This is what potentially works so well for Boston, with a healthy
Jonathan Papelbon nailing down the ninth inning. Saito is slated to join countryman
Hideki Okajima as a primary set-up man in the late innings. One wonders if a healthy Saito could cause the Red Sox to shift
Justin Masterson back to the starting rotation and lead to a trade of someone like
Clay Buchholz for catching help. Saito's guaranteed money is believed to be in the neighborhood of $2 million.
It is impossible
not to contrast the Red Sox spending pattern (approximately $14 million in guaranteed money to six players, including catcher
Josh Bard) to the drunken sailor spending of the New York Yankees ($450 million on three players). If it's a case of "You get what you pay for," it could be a long, frustrating summer for Red Sox fans. MLB Home Plate on XM Radio feels that the Red Sox spent smart money on hungry players with something to prove. Likely, not everyone will return to splendid health in 2009, but the potential is there for something special. The Sox have used January so far to add depth to the bench, the starting rotation, and the bullpen. It's likely that the remainder of the month and perhaps into February will be used to determine one way or another what to do about the catching position.